Nov 2025 I did 2 days of diving in Utila after a week in Roatan. I give Utila a slight edge for the actual diving, and Roatan an edge for locale. One fact I can verify: Utila is great value. I wasn't planning to go to Utila as I prioritized Roatan as my only stop amongst the Bay Islands. But as fate would have it, my moto broke down after I returned to La Ceiba from Roatan, and I needed to wait for parts. So I headed to Utila. Things could be worse (like being stuck in La Cei